 Brooklyn McDuffie | Eastern Florida State College | 2022 |
 Dani Grenon | Eastern Florida State College | 2022 |
 Amaya Quintal | Eastern Florida State College | 2021 |
 Jessica Martin | Eastern Florida State College | 2021 |
 Grace Hanks | Palm Beach Atlantic | 2020 |
 Ashleigh Sweat | Webber Int'l Univ | 2020 |
 Lily Hogenson | Eastern Florida State College | 2020 |
 Jordan Tomberlin | Salem College | 2019 |
 Lexy Denaburg | UCLA - Volleyball | 2019 |
 Jojo Michaels | University of Central Florida | 2019 |
 Julia Martin | University of North Florida | 2018 |
 Keli Lindquist | University of Central Florida | 2017 |
 Kellie Krygier | Florida Institute of Technology | 2016 |
 Robyn Herman | University of West Florida | 2016 |
 Jaime Farls | Eastern Florida State College | 2016 |
 Emily Plotz | Stetson University | 2016 |
 Kaley Verpaele | University of Alabama | 2016 |
 Olivia Bergau | Florida State University | 2015 |
 Audrey Bone | Eastern Florida State College | 2015 |
 Kelsey Lewis | Polk State College | 2013 |
 Amanda Wilkin | University of Central Florida | 2012 |
 Summer Schults | Lynn University | 2012 |
| Shannon Anderson | Lynn University | 2012 |
 Sydney Drinkwater | Florida Atlantic University | 2012 |
 Kirstie Schults | Lynn University | 2011 |
 Lindsay Kostner | Bryan College | 2011 |
 Kaitlyn Cauffman | Nova Southeastern University | 2011 |
 Meredith Testa | University of West Florida | 2011 |
 Hannah Linton | Flagler College | 2010 |
 Chelsea Seng | Eastern Florida State College | 2009 |
 Alyssa Rochester | Troy University | 2009 |
 Holly Payne | Flagler College | 2009 |
 Sadie McLean | University of North Florida | 2008 |
| Megan Stone | Florida Institute of Technology | 2008 |
| Cara Bortz | University of Central Florida | 2006 |
 Kacie Brewer | University of South Carolina | 2006 |
 Natalie Feller | Lynn University | 2006 |
| Bethany Barron | Erskine College | 2005 |
| Kim Coapstick | Tusculum University | 2004 |
| Chrisy Awtonomow | Tusculum University | 2004 |
| Kristen Huppert | Mars Hill University | 2004 |
 Stephanie Hill | Embry Riddle | 2004 |
| Lea Kyle | Stony Brook University | 2001 |
 Nicole Johnston | Embry Riddle | 2001 |
| Lisa Weaklim | Stetson University | 2000 |
| Alicia Davis | Liberty University | 1999 |
| Meredith Osikowicz | Barry University | 1997 |
| Liz Stites | Jacksonville University | 1996 |
| Shannon Sullivan | John Carroll | 1994 |
| Jean Zabin | Villanova University | 1992 |
| Krista Hayes | Coker University | 1989 |
